home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=90TT1079>
- <link 89TT2605>
- <title>
- Apr. 30, 1990: Vietnam:A War On Poverty
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1990
- Apr. 30, 1990 Vietnam 15 Years Later
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- VIETNAM, Page 22
- COVER STORIES
- A War on Poverty
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p>Finally at peace, Vietnam is struggling to open up its economy
- and close the gap between the backward North and bustling South
- </p>
- <p>By William Stewart/Hanoi
- </p>
- <p> The scene is far more grim than anything portrayed in the
- decrepit U.S. veterans hospital in Born on the Fourth of July.
- In a forgotten corner of Ha Bac province, about 40 miles from
- Hanoi, 200 Vietnamese army veterans, many paralyzed from the
- waist down, eke out their lives in a primitive government
- shelter. Tucked away from the nation's gaze, they are among
- more than 10,000 severely wounded veterans from the four wars
- Vietnam has fought since 1945. An additional 300,000 disabled
- soldiers are scattered throughout Vietnam, doing the best they
- can without the help of the government. In wheelchairs, the
- ex-soldiers at Ha Bac move quietly among the low-slung
- buildings, a poignant and disturbing sight.
- </p>
- <p> Like their American counterparts, the patients at Ha Bac are
- both proud and reticent, resigned to their wounds, sometimes
- angry, often confused. Says Vu Trung Hien, 43, paralyzed since
- 1968 by a shrapnel wound in the back sustained in Phuoc Long
- province: "I did my duty. But after I was wounded, I wondered
- if the war was right or wrong. It cost so much. I still
- wonder." His roommate, Hoang Dinh Trung, 39, was similarly
- disabled in 1972 in Quang Tri province during a B-52 raid. "I
- was only 18 when I was mobilized," he says. "Looking back to
- wartime, it was awful. Really awful. I'm afraid of any more
- wars." When told that many American veterans share his feelings,
- he says tentatively, almost shyly, "I'd like them to come see
- us, to see how we live."
- </p>
- <p> The voices of disabled Vietnamese soldiers are only a small
- echo of the sometimes hopeful but often disenchanted and
- uncertain views voiced everywhere in Vietnam. Fifteen years
- after the fighting ended on April 30, 1975, the country remains
- impoverished and embittered. While it has been at peace since
- most Vietnamese troops left Cambodia last September, there is
- great discontent over living conditions and an annual per
- capita income of less than $200, far below that of South
- Vietnam in 1975. Last year 75,000 boat people set sail for the
- refugee camps of Hong Kong and Southeast Asia, attempting to
- escape not so much an oppressive regime as grinding poverty.
- Free-market economic reforms begun in 1986 have sparked a
- revival in the cities, but they have yet to improve living
- standards in the countryside, where 80% of Vietnam's 65 million
- people still live.
- </p>
- <p> The moves toward a market economy have been hobbled by
- Vietnam's economic and diplomatic isolation. Hanoi and
- Washington have long disagreed on how to restore relations, and
- the U.S. strengthened a 1975 trade embargo following Vietnam's
- 1978 invasion of Cambodia. Other industrial countries,
- including Japan, are waiting for a U.S. lead before committing
- themselves to major trade and investment. Meanwhile, the Soviet
- Union has served notice that it will drastically curtail the
- aid it has provided in the past, especially fertilizers,
- structural steel and critical oil supplies.
- </p>
- <p> North and South were formally united in July 1976, but for
- all practical purposes Vietnam still consists of two countries.
- According to Nguyen Xuan Oanh, twice acting Prime Minister of
- South Vietnam and currently an economic adviser to Hanoi, the
- economic infrastructure in the South remains about 35 years
- ahead of that in the North, despite great efforts to bridge the
- gap. The differences are immediately apparent between Hanoi and
- Ho Chi Minh City, which is still called Saigon, even by local
- officials.
- </p>
- <p> Hanoi, with a population of 3 million, has retained its
- architectural integrity as a once lovely French colonial
- capital. The city was scarcely damaged by U.S. bombs. But the
- roads and bridges are dilapidated and marred with potholes, and
- haphazardly repaired electrical lines have made firetraps of
- many public buildings. Although Vietnam has designated 1990 the
- "Year of Tourism," Hanoi hardly boasts a hotel worthy of the
- name.
- </p>
- <p> Yet there is a liveliness about the city, an authenticity
- as a national capital that somehow always eluded Saigon. May
- 19 marks the 100th birthday of Ho Chi Minh, the man who fought
- the Japanese, the French, the Americans and his own countrymen
- to win an independent, unified nation. For the past month,
- Hanoi has played host to thousands of visitors, foreign and
- Vietnamese alike, as they paid homage to the frail little man
- with a will of iron. The pilgrims move slowly past Ho's body
- lying on a glass-enclosed platform in the neo-Stalinist marble
- mausoleum, stopping only for a short, formal bow.
- </p>
- <p> Outside, Hanoi's narrow tree-lined streets are filled with
- bicycles and pedicabs, for private cars are a rarity in the
- city. In the busy market area, customers crowd into a tiny but
- popular cafe that serves white coffee with a whipped raw egg
- to help ward off the pervasive dampness of the rainy season.
- Around the corner on Hang Gai Street, shoppers wander past
- privately owned clothing and novelty shops that are little more
- than window fronts. Nevertheless, they are the busiest stores
- in Hanoi. One of them is owned by Dao Thi Huan, 71, a retired
- government worker. For her, life is much better than it was
- even five years ago, though she feels that living standards are
- still low. The long war is a receding memory. "In the past I
- was angry, but not now," she says. "It's over. I gave up my
- anger." A few doors away sits Ngo Thanh Binh, 26. A university
- graduate with a degree in economics, Binh has been unable to
- find a job. To make ends meet, he works in his parents' shop
- selling jeans. "It's been very difficult for me to get a job
- as an economist," he says. "I need to know more English because
- our country is in an opening, developing stage. We need even
- more openness."
- </p>
- <p> The budding economic energy has spread even further north.
- Six thousand people a day cross the Chinese border at Dong
- Dang. Going into China, they take mostly local foodstuffs;
- returning, they bring Chinese machine tools and kitchenwares
- carried on their backs, the heavy packages balanced at either
- end of a bamboo pole. The goods are modern, but silhouetted
- against the sky, the endless stream of peasants, workers and
- merchants is a scene from timeless Asia.
- </p>
- <p> A thousand miles to the south, Ho Chi Minh City basks in the
- hot sun at the end of the dry season. But the difference is
- more than a matter of weather. Roads are in better repair, and
- the streets are clogged with motor-scooter and automobile
- traffic. New hotels and fresh paint are everywhere as the city
- asserts its claim to be the home of Vietnam's indomitable
- entrepreneurial spirit.
- </p>
- <p> Anchored in the Saigon River is the Saigon Floating Hotel,
- offering single rooms at $150 a night and a BLT sandwich--"Ho
- Chi Minh-style"--for $8.50. It is crowded with Hong Kong,
- Singaporean and European businessmen. On Dong Khoi Street, the
- Continental Palace Hotel has undergone a complete renovation.
- The famous "Continental shelf," once an open-air terrace where
- American journalists and government officials camped out, is
- now enclosed and air-conditioned. The Rex, formerly a U.S. Army
- billet, has reopened as a luxury hotel, and the Majestic,
- facing the Saigon River, has been spruced up. The hotels take
- only hard currency.
- </p>
- <p> In the past year the city has encouraged the opening of
- "mini-hotels" for Vietnamese visitors. The managers are often
- enterprising city employees eager to make more money. Says
- Nguyen Cong Ai, vice chairman of the local People's Committee:
- "Our private economy is much stronger now. We are learning the
- lessons of the market. We want to cooperate with foreign
- cities, to be an open door for Vietnam." Metropolitan Saigon
- has a population of 3.9 million. The port itself and textile
- and garment manufacturing are the city's biggest industries.
- </p>
- <p> The revival is attributable almost entirely to Vietnam's own
- perestroika, or doi moi, a program of radical economic
- "renovation" begun in 1986. Says Le Dang Doanh, a senior
- government economist and a principal architect of the program:
- "Vietnam does not consider Marxism to be holy dogma. We need
- to be creative." Only a few years ago, the state accounted for
- close to half of national income. Now it generates only 28% of
- national income, Doanh notes, while private enterprise makes
- up 40% and the remainder is a mixture of public and private
- ventures. The reforms include the abolition of subsidized prices
- and the reorganization and separation of commercial banks from
- government banks. The state has also adopted a favorable
- foreign-investment law and changed investment policy to assign
- top priority to food production.
- </p>
- <p> Although all land is owned by the state, a revised contract
- system between farmers and government cooperatives gives
- individual farmers control of the land and production for 15
- to 30 years. Farmers grow what they want and sell at the market
- price. Largely as a result, Vietnam has become the world's
- third biggest rice exporter, after Thailand and the U.S. The
- turnaround is remarkable, given the near famine conditions that
- existed in the spring of 1988 in parts of central and northern
- Vietnam. A further indication of improved conditions in the
- North is the sharp reduction in the numbers of boat people
- arriving in Hong Kong, down from almost 1,800 in March 1989 to
- 730 in the same month this year.
- </p>
- <p> Meanwhile, the annual inflation rate has been cut from 700%
- in 1988 to 50%. The goal, says former Prime Minister Oanh, is
- to bring it down to about 12% to 15% by year's end. This has
- been done through tough austerity measures, part of a
- stabilization plan carried out in cooperation with the
- International Monetary Fund. The dong, Vietnam's currency, has
- stabilized at a black-market rate of about 5,000 to the dollar,
- not far from the official rate of 4,500. Still, in the past two
- years foreigners have invested only $850 million in Vietnam,
- most of that in off-shore oil exploration.
- </p>
- <p> Given these problems and challenges, it is not surprising
- that the Vietnamese leadership has been alarmed by the
- startling and rapid changes in Eastern Europe. But political
- reforms were emphatically rejected earlier this month in a
- closed session of the 8th plenum of Vietnam's Communist Party.
- While the plenum promised to revitalize the party's frayed
- relations with the people, it also fired an outspoken liberal
- member of the Politburo, Tran Xuan Bach. That leaves only one
- liberal in the 13-member ruling body, Foreign Minister Nguyen
- Co Thach.
- </p>
- <p> To make up for losses in Soviet aid, China has reportedly
- offered to provide Vietnam with $2 billion in assistance. In
- return, Beijing is said to have demanded assurances that the
- Vietnamese will launch no Gorbachev-style political reforms.
- </p>
- <p> Vietnam has seen no major public demonstrations for greater
- democracy, though there has been a lively debate in some of the
- state-controlled press and among academicians and trade unions.
- In part this may be because Hanoi has ruled with a lighter
- touch than Beijing. Says Tran Phuoc Duong, the
- American-educated rector of Can Tho University, deep in the
- Mekong Delta: "Something has happened. There has been a lot of
- internal relaxation. The pace of change has taken people by
- surprise."
- </p>
- <p> Tran Bach Dang, a political adviser to General Secretary
- Nguyen Van Linh, told a group of foreign reporters that if
- pluralism were allowed tomorrow, there would be 200 political
- parties the next day. Notes a senior government official:
- "Factionalism has been the bane of our national existence. We
- are still two countries, though I fought to make it one."
- </p>
- <p> The weight of Vietnamese history indicates that the official
- is right. Nevertheless, there is more to celebrate in Vietnam
- than the 100th birthday of Ho Chi Minh. Vietnamese in the North
- and South alike are beginning to hope their country can
- transcend its old divisions and enter a new age of prosperity.
- In Hanoi, Nguyen Van Su, 75, sits in front of his sewing
- machine in his own little shop. Says he: "I remember when Ho
- Chi Minh declared independence. We all liked it. Now the
- government is calling for reform. I like that too. It's the
- direction the whole world is moving in, isn't it?"
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-